Are you looking for a safe, trustworthy place to sell your gold or silver in Amelia Island, Florida? At First and Best Precious Metals, we proudly serve the Amelia Island community with honest evaluations, transparent testing, and a faith-driven commitment to putting people first. We don’t pressure—we provide clear answers, fair quotes, and peace of mind every step of the way.
Why Amelia Island Residents Trust Us
Personal, One-on-One Service—On Your Schedule
We don’t believe in rushing or treating you like a number. Whether you live on Amelia Island year-round or you’re just here for the season, we make it easy to meet on your terms.
- Appointments are private, relaxed, and never rushed
- Concierge-style service that respects your time
- No waiting rooms, no lines—just real conversations
- We meet with you in a safe, professional space where you’re fully at ease
Fair Prices. No Secrets. No Pressure.
You deserve to know exactly what your gold and silver are worth—and why. That’s why we show you everything, explain every detail, and let you decide what’s right for you.
- All testing is done in front of you—nothing hidden
- Real-time pricing based on today’s live market
- We walk you through your options without pressure
- The goal isn’t the sale—it’s your peace of mind
A Company Built on Faith, Serving Northeast Florida
Our clients choose us because they share our values. We’re rooted in Biblical principles, and everything we do is guided by honesty, service, and respect—for people, not just profits.
- Serving Amelia Island, Fernandina Beach, Nocatee, and beyond
- Trusted by families, retirees, and local business owners
- Many of our clients come through word of mouth—that speaks volumes
- We’re more than a precious metals company—we’re a company with conviction
How Selling Gold or Silver Works with Us
If you’re in Amelia Island and thinking about selling your gold or silver, you deserve a process that feels honest, simple, and respectful. We walk you through every step, explain everything clearly, and never pressure you—because that’s just how we believe business should be done.
Honest Testing You Can See for Yourself
We use professional-grade tools to ensure accuracy—and we test everything right in front of you so there are no doubts or surprises.
- We use the Sigma Metalytics Scanner, trusted across the industry for precise, non-invasive testing
- Your items are never scratched, clipped, or sent offsite
- We walk you through the process and explain what we’re seeing
- Whether it’s coins, bullion, or jewelry, we handle each piece with care and respect
It’s important to us that you feel fully informed and completely confident at every step.
Transparent Quotes—Every Time, in Writing
Once we’ve tested your metals, we’ll give you a clear, no-obligation offer based on real-time market values. Nothing is rushed or hidden.
- All offers are documented in writing—no “verbal guesstimates”
- We explain the math behind every number so you’re never in the dark
- You’re free to accept, decline, or take time to think it over
- There are no fees, no pressure, and no fine print
We believe in treating people the way we’d want to be treated.
What to Bring to Your Appointment
A smooth appointment starts with just a few simple things. Here’s what to have on hand:
- The items you’d like evaluated (gold, silver, coins, bullion, jewelry, etc.)
- A valid photo ID (required for all precious metals transactions in Florida)
- Any original paperwork or certificates (optional but helpful)
- Questions—bring them! We’re here to help, not hurry
And most importantly, bring yourself—we’ll take care of the rest.
What We Buy from Clients in Amelia Island, FL
We buy a wide range of gold and silver items, always with transparency and respect.
- Gold coins
- Silver rounds
- 90% junk silver
- Bars (gold and silver)
- And more
If you’re unsure whether we’ll take it, just ask. We’re happy to take a look and give you a straightforward answer.
Schedule Your Private Appointment in Amelia Island Florida
Call or text (904) 624‑1231 to set up your secure, no-pressure visit. We’ll meet you at a time that works for you—always with professionalism, discretion, and the personal care you deserve.
Ready to Sell with Confidence? Let First and Best Guide You.
Whether you’re selling $5,000 or $500,000 in precious metals, we’ll walk you through each step with clarity, integrity, and personal care. At First and Best Precious Metals, our mission is rooted in stewardship—not sales pressure—because doing right by you matters more than making a deal.
