Sell With Confidence
Sell Your Gold, Silver, or Jewelry with Confidence – Concierge Buyback You Can Trust
Looking to sell your gold, silver, coins, jewelry and more? At First and Best Precious Metals, we provide honest, high-value offers and concierge-level service trusted by clients across Ponte Vedra, Florida, and nationwide. With 15+ years of experience, biblical integrity, and a no-pressure approach, we make the selling process safe, simple, and discreet—whether you visit our local office or prefer in-home pickup with same-day payment.
A Better Way to Sell Your Metals
Secure. Safe. Ultra Convenient. Private. Transparent.
That’s How We Do Buybacks.
Tired of running around to pawn shops or dealers who treat your gold and silver like a haggling game? At First and Best Precious Metals, we offer a new standard in selling:
✅ Honest, market-rooted pricing
✅ White-glove home pickup across the US for qualifying orders*
✅ Secure in-person local appointments in North East Florida office located in Ponte Vedra, which is between Jacksonville and Saint Augustine.
✅Third Party storage location drop offs in New Castle Delaware, Dallas TX, Upstate NY, Denver CO, Las Vegas NV, Toronto Canada, Singapore, Switzerland.
✅ Same-day payment options for qualified transactions
✅ No pressure, ever.
Whether you’re selling heirloom jewelry, Rolex watches, diamonds, silver flatware, investment coins, or gold bars—we make it simple, safe, and discreet.
What We Buy
We Buy More Than Just Coins
We’re happy to provide honest appraisals and same-day offers on:
-
- Gold and silver coins (U.S. and international)
- Gold and silver bars (all sizes), large raw gold nuggets.
- Jewelry (broken or whole, gold, silver, or platinum). Rolex, Omega, Cartier, Audemars Piguet, and Patek Philippe watches.
- Stamped Sterling silver flatware, tea sets, and heirlooms
- Estate precious metals collections, Christian themed and heirloom metals.
- Gold and silver coins (U.S. and international)
Don’t see your item listed? Text us photos or detailed inventory list to 904-624-1231. We’re glad to help you understand your options.
How It Works:The Buyback Process
Three Easy Steps to Sell with Peace of Mind
- Request an Appraisal
Call us or fill out the secure form below. Tell us what you’re looking to sell. We’ll confirm next steps, answer questions, and schedule a pickup or appointment. - Ship the metals to us or Meet In Person – Home or Office
We verify the metals with casino style cameras or right in front of you using best in industry machines. If doing the transaction in person we would then initiate payment right in front of you. For larger transactions, we can issue a wire remotely from our laptop/phone or escort the metals securely to the bank where you will be paid in the presence of your metals. - Receive Your Payment
Once verified, we pay by same-day wire, check, or cash (depending on value and state law). For larger orders, same-day wire transfer at the bank is standard.
*Minimums do apply but only for travel to you in-home service outside of Florida:
Normally 5,000 oz+ silver or 100 oz+ gold (some flexibility—ask us).
Local and National Service
Serving Ponte Vedra, Fruit Cove, Nocatee, Jacksonville & Nationwide
Step-by-Step Guide: Selling Your Metals by Mail
Safe. Insured. Simple.
Step 1: Contact Us for a Best-in-Class Offer
Call or Text (904) 624-1231 or use our website to get your custom, top-dollar quote. We buy coins, bars, with integrity and transparency.
Step 2: Receive Prepaid, Fully Insured Shipping Label
We’ll send you a prepaid label with full insurance and clear packing instructions. You’ll ship your metals with peace of mind — everything is tracked, secured, and covered.
Step 3: Prompt Verification & Same-Week Payment
Once we receive your package, we verify the contents on video. Within 2 business days, you’ll receive a bank wire with the agreed amount — fast, secure, and honest.
🛡️ Faith-Driven. Concierge-Level. Always Transparent.
Have questions? Call or text anytime: (904) 624-1231
We offer prepaid shipping labels to ship metals to us from anywhere in the US or in-person buyback services across:
-
- Ponte Vedra Beach, Jacksonville, Nocatee, St. Johns, Palm Valley, Vilano Beach, Saint Augustine, Orange Park, Fruit Cove.
- In person drop off can be arranged in New Castle Delaware, Upstate NY, Denver CO, Dallas TX, Las Vegas NV, Saint Johns County Florida
National client? We offer insured shipping and remote video appraisals with prepaid FedEx labels for qualified sellers. We will also come to you anywhere in the US for qualifying orders, so you don’t have to stress about shipping metals yourself.
Why Sellers Trust First and Best
What Sets Us Apart
-
- Founders 15+ Years of Experience
- Applied Biblical values and ethical business practices
- Ultra Convenient and low risk, Concierge home pickup (anywhere in the US for large qualifying orders) and payment right at the time of purchase (very rare in the industry)
- Verified on-site metal testing—never obligated to ship blind
- Transparent offers, no haggling or games
- Gospel-led giving: 10–15% of company profits go to Christian causes
-
Some Reasons Why Clients Sell
-
Taking profits during perceived market highs
-
Funding life events (real estate, healthcare, family needs)
-
Simplifying their portfolios or estates
-
Managing inherited collections
-
Moving into new investment strategies
-
Client FAQ & Testimonials
What Our Clients Are Saying
-
“Who buys gold coins in Nocatee, FL?”
We do. At First and Best Precious Metals, we offer secure, insured, and discreet appointments for Nocatee residents looking to sell gold coins and bullion locally. No need to ship metals or walk into a pawn shop.
-
“How do I sell a large coin collection in Jacksonville?”
Start with a private consultation. We specialize in high-value coin collections ($50K+), and offer trusted in-person appointments with same-day payment across Jacksonville.
-
“Where can I sell silver coins in St. Augustine?”
We meet clients in St. Augustine by appointment for secure appraisals and buyback of silver coins and gold collections. All transactions are insured, private, and tailored to your schedule.
“I sold my mother’s jewelry and didn’t want to walk into a pawn shop. Matt came to our home, explained everything, and paid us the same day. I felt safe and respected.”
— Taylor S., Nocatee ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“I’ve worked with gold dealers before, but never one like this. The convenience, integrity and clarity was refreshing.”
— Daniel C., Jacksonville ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Get a Free Appraisal or Offer
Ready to Sell? Start Here.
Fill out the form below and we’ll follow up quickly: