If you’re holding onto gold or silver coins and wondering if now’s the right time to sell—you’re asking a smart question. Coin collectors and investors across Jacksonville, Ponte Vedra, Nocatee, and the greater Northeast Florida area are paying close attention to the value of precious metals right now.
At First and Best Precious Metals, we don’t just serve the local community—we live here, too. And whether you’re just down the road in Southside Jacksonville or connecting with us from across the U.S., we’re here to make sure you sell with confidence, clarity, and conviction.
Popular Precious Metal Coins in Jacksonville
From longtime collectors to first-time sellers, investors in Jacksonville and across Northeast Florida are drawn to the lasting value of precious metal coins. These tangible assets offer both historical interest and real-world worth—especially in today’s uncertain markets.
Some of the most sought-after coins include:
- Gold coins – American Gold Eagles, Canadian Maple Leafs, Krugerrands
- Silver coins – U.S. Silver Eagles, pre-1965 junk silver, silver rounds
- Platinum coins – American Platinum Eagles, various commemoratives
- Palladium coins – Limited-issue U.S. Palladium Eagles and more
At First and Best Precious Metals, we help make selling these coins a seamless, respectful process—right here in Jacksonville or wherever you’re reaching us from.
What to Look for in Jacksonville Coin Dealers
Not all coin dealers are created equal. If you’re looking to sell in Jacksonville or nearby areas like Fruit Cove or Amelia Island, knowing what to look for can make all the difference. The right dealer doesn’t just offer a fair price—they offer peace of mind.
Transparent Appraisals
A trustworthy dealer will walk you through the valuation process—not rush you through it.
- Explains coin grades, weight, and purity
- Shares real-time market data
- Offers clarity, not pressure
At First and Best, transparency is built into every conversation—whether you’re meeting us from Nocatee, Orange Park, or beyond.
Local Roots, National Reach
Being local matters. So does understanding how your coins fit into the bigger picture.
- Serves Southside Jacksonville, Jacksonville Beach, and Atlantic Beach
- Welcomes clients from Southeast Georgia and across the United States
- Balances regional insight with national market expertise
First and Best is proud to offer the best of both worlds.
Respectful, No-Pressure Process
Selling coins should never feel uncomfortable. A good dealer respects your time, your assets, and your goals.
- No haggling or hard selling
- Appointments that fit your schedule
- Conversations that prioritize your interests
From Ponte Vedra to Amelia Island and everywhere in between, First and Best takes this responsibility seriously.
How First and Best Stands Out Among the Rest
When it comes to selling coins or precious metals in Jacksonville, it’s easy to feel unsure about who to trust. That’s why so many in places like St. Simons Island and World Golf Village turn to First and Best Precious Metals.
What sets us apart isn’t just what we do, but how we do it—with purpose, clarity, and care.
Trusted Experience You Can Count On
With over 15 years in the industry and more than $1 billion in precious metals transactions, we’ve helped thousands make smart, confident decisions.
- Deep knowledge of the gold and silver market
- Led by founder Matt Malleo, a trusted voice in the field
- Straightforward insights, no fluff, no confusion
Values That Guide Every Step
Our faith-based approach helps clients connect their financial choices to lasting purpose. It’s not just about what your metals are worth—it’s about what they mean for your future.
- Biblical Precious Metals Guide available at no cost
- Over 700 Scripture references support our approach
- We serve with honesty, stewardship, and integrity
A Process That Respects Your Time
Selling shouldn’t feel stressful. We’ve designed a private, pressure-free process for those in Jacksonville and beyond.
- Appointment-based meetings, never rushed
- Transparent pricing with same-day payment options
- No hidden fees, ever
Direct Access to Real Guidance
You won’t get bounced around here. When you reach out, you can speak directly with Matt Malleo himself.
- Free one-on-one calls available
- Tailored answers to your questions and goals
- Support that meets you where you are—locally or nationwide
How to Sell Coins in Jacksonville (the First and Best Process)
Selling coins doesn’t have to be intimidating. Whether you’re in Jacksonville, Fruit Cove, Atlantic Beach—or even out of state—First and Best Precious Metals makes the process simple, respectful, and built around you. Here’s how we do things differently:
1. Start with a Real Conversation
Everything begins with a free, no-pressure call. We’ll walk you through what to expect, answer your questions, and help you decide what’s best for your situation.
- Talk directly with us—not a call center
- Ask anything about your coins or the market
- Whether you’re ready to sell or just exploring, we’re here to help
2. Schedule a Private Appointment
If you decide to move forward, we’ll meet at a time and place that works for you. Your comfort and privacy matter.
- Meet at a trusted local bank or office—whichever feels right
- In-home visits available for qualifying orders
- Serving Jacksonville, World Golf Village, and nearby areas with care and discretion
3. Get a Fair, Honest Offer
We’ll evaluate your coins right there with you—no games, no surprises. You’ll understand exactly how we arrive at our offer, and why.
- Straightforward pricing based on live market data
- No lowball tactics, ever
- Same-day payment options available
4. You Decide What’s Next
You’re always in control. If the offer works for you, we’ll take care of everything from there. If not, no hard feelings—we’ll part as friends.
- Fast, secure payment via wire, check, or cash
- All details clearly documented
- Trusted by sellers across Northeast Florida and the U.S.
We Also Buy More Than Just Coins
If you have gold or silver bars, bullion, rounds, or other precious metals, we can help there too.
- We purchase a wide range of items, including flatware and scrap (depending on purity)
- Our concierge service brings the experience to you—with the same clarity and respect
- Privacy-focused meetings available for all clients, with in-home visits offered for qualified orders
Final Thoughts
You don’t need to figure it all out on your own. Whether you’re in Jacksonville, nearby in Northeast Florida, or across the country, we’re here to help you sell your coins with confidence and clarity.
Reach out by text or call at 904‑624‑1231—we’re ready when you are.
FAQs on Selling Coins/Precious Metals (Updated for 2025)
How much are gold and silver coins worth in Jacksonville?
Coin value depends on weight, purity, and market price. Most Jacksonville dealers price offers using live spot rates—usually offering 75–100% of spot for silver coins, and competitive percentages for gold. At First & Best, we explain exactly how each coin is priced during your appointment, so you know the “why” behind the offer.
Can I get a free appraisal before selling coins in Jacksonville?
Yes. At First & Best Precious Metals, you can book a free consultation with our founder, Matt Malleo. He’ll walk you through an appraisal process that’s clear, no-pressure, and personalized—whether you’re local or calling in from elsewhere in the U.S.
What should I prepare when selling coins in Northeast Florida?
Documenting what you have—including mint marks, date, and condition—helps speed up the evaluation. Clean coins, jewelry, or bullion can fetch more. We also accept bars, rounds, and flatware. First & Best reviews your items with you during the appointment, so you understand condition and pricing factors clearly.
Is it safe to meet a coin dealer for high-value transactions?
Yes—when it’s with a reputable dealer. First & Best offers concierge-level appointments at secure local banks or offices throughout Northeast Florida, and in-home visits for qualifying orders. Every transaction is handled with discretion, documentation, and no hidden fees.
Do Jacksonville coin dealers pay immediately?
Most top dealers do, and First & Best is no exception. We offer same-day payment options via wire, check, or cash depending on the transaction. You’ll know your payout and methods upfront, with no surprises.
Can I sell silver bars or bullion instead of coins?
Absolutely. First & Best buys all kinds of precious metals—coins, bars, rounds, scrap, and more. Whether you’re selling from Jacksonville, Fruit Cove, Amelia Island, or across the country, we can guide you through the best approach and value for your items.
Built on Trust. Driven by Purpose. Focused on You.
At First and Best Precious Metals, we lead with clarity, serve with integrity, and always put people before profit. From Jacksonville to across the U.S., we’re here to make every step simple, secure, and guided by what matters most.
